Saturday, 31 October 2026

Wide and Obscure: the Nikkor 18mm f/4 AI

The 18mm f/4 AI is another lens documented on Nikon Thousand and One Nights tale. The ultra-wide lens was produced from 1977-1982 as a premium lens coming from the New-Nikkor/K incarrnation, and was replaced by slightly faster 18mm f/3.5.

This 18mm f/4 is not very common on the used market in the UK - Roland Vink's data showing around 9000 New-Nikkor/K and AI units produced - and when it's available is reasonably pricey. It has a mixed reputation as per Richard Haw's usual detailed write up and further feedback from the Nikon Gear forum.

Cosmetically it's an interesting looking lens for sure.



Even in its short AI production run it had a number of AI makeovers. The lens featured a 86mm filter ring and slightly bulbuous focus ring that was slightly remminisent of the 20mm f/4 AI slip on HK-3 lens hood in the way the focus grip is altered.

The optical construction is a 13/9 design that was debutted in the 1974 Photokina show (for the K/New-Nikkor lens). The optical design bridged a gap between the huge ultra super wide 15mm and (relatively) smaller 20mm Nikkors at the time and allowed the 18mm lens to be relatively compact for the optical consturction that it carried:


(C) Nikon - 18mm f/4 AI optical cross section

From MIR photography in Malaysia - also lists marketting materials for depth of field

Performance

The lens has some very vintage characteristics. Sharpness at the wider apertures isn't a little above average but not spectacular at closer apertures; at infinity/extreme far distances can be quite mushy - it seems better closer at these apertures. Stopped down to around f/8 it gets much much better but any modern day lens at f/8 is going to be very good. Nikon's 1001 Nights Tale summarises as:

f/4 (maximum aperture)

While resolution is relatively good at the center of the frame, flare increases gradually and sharpness drops as image height increases. However, image quality is sufficiently maintained for practical use in most circumstances. Naturally, resolution is insufficient at the extreme edges of the frame. There is also some peripheral illumination falloff, but I think colors are good with little bleed.

f/5.6

Stopping down the aperture to f/5.6 increases sharpness, especially near the center of the frame. While there is little change in resolution throughout most of the frame, flare is reduced for a sharper image. There is also less peripheral illumination falloff.

f/8 to f/11

Flare is eliminated for significantly greater resolution at the edges of the frame. A satisfactory level of sharpness is achieved throughout nearly the entire frame. Image quality drops only at the extreme edges of the frame. The f/11 to f/16 range of aperture settings seems best for regular use.

[...]

If sharpness is the goal, the best results would likely be achieved at an aperture setting of f/11 to f/16.

Sharpness




Far distance sharpness is not great across all apertures and looks also like a lens resolution issue:

f/4 .. f/11 - centre slice of frame

Mid distance sharpness is better than far:



focus on lowrise yellow building

And near distance sharpness is adequate:








At near focus (~0.5m), all images below centre crops:




It feels like f/5.6 is sharpest at on this copy, as apposed to other references that cite f/8 - f/11: this could be due to mechanical issues with this lens (see later). For reference comparison, heres a 18-55mm kit lens - the older 18mm f/4 AI is still better but not by much.



Light Sources in Frame

Flare, Ghosting

It's performance with bright light in the frame is good: it's very flare resistant but can be suspetable to ghosts that will appear across the frame. Chromatic aberrations are not so noticable even though its there.










The era of the lens is clearly demonstrated with the way it handles point light sources with its classic blooming glow (see the street lamps and mid-low office lights in the background) and very much like the 20mm f/4 AI.



Sunstars

Decent sun-stars can be acheived:



Distortion

One of the criticisms of this lens is the moustache distortion:



Colour Rendition

Colour is good and comparable to the contemporary 20mm wides - DX/crop images below are colour corrected to a consistent WB using the WhiBal reference card. The 18mm f/4 AI vignettes heavily but you see the minor effects on the corners (even in DX crop).



The other images referenced above are colour correct and no additional saturation have been added as part of the RAW file exports but it seems that its slightly less saturated than modern kit lenses (see the 0.5m shots) and with slightly less contrast.


click for larger - all under same flash exposure (no changes to light), same camera body, consistent colour corrected, same default RAW conversion settings

I've choosen the colour comparison against an old Nikon kit lens, the very common 50mm Series-E (whose optical formula was carried into the 50mm f/1.8 AF-D) and a contemporary 20mm f/4 AI.

18mm f/4 AI vs.. Color & Saturation (CIE L*a*b*) Contrast Sharpness & Detail
20mm f/4 AI 18mm f/4 AI renders subtly cooler than the 20mm f/4 AI which has modestly higher yellow 20mm f/4 AI has better small dark details (such as the Raspberry Pi's black connectors) with brighter specular snap 20mm f/4 AI reads slightly punchier due to higher local contrast.
18-55mm f/3.5-5.6 DX (@ 50mm) 18mm f/4 AI closely trails the DX kit lens in saturation as expected but not by a visually massive margin DX kit lens has a deeper contrast, seen in rendering the Pi's black jacks and IC chips much darker; 18mm f/4 AI exhibits softer micro-contrast with slightly lifted shadow tones DX kit lens is sharper
50mm f/1.8 Series E 18mm f/4 AI produces more saturated primaries colours when looking at LAB values: blue (C* 58.5 vs. 55.1), red (C* 78.8 vs. 75.2), and yellow (C* 74.1 vs. 71.2) Series-E 50mm delivers crisper dark tones Series-E 50mm is the sharpest lens in this set

Vignetting is heavy wide open on full frame images - many images above are on DX.

Servicing

This lens isn't hard to service but it does have an unusual set up for the optical block that typically houses the lens elements and the aperture mechanism.

  • Remove the shallow hood and use lens spanner to remove the front optical block

    Set the lens at infinity and aperture at f/22





    The front element is bulbuous so be careful how you sit this - sit it in the removed hood and set aside



  • Remove the rear optical block

    The rear block is secured by 3x secures and has a guide pin (see the pin at the 5 o'clock position below)





    Note the position of various parts - you may wish to mark the inner brass helicoid for the orientation after removing the focus ring for easy reassembly, as this is at infinity and at f/22 (note the position of the aperture fork)

    On the optial block you will see the hard focus stop - on the image below its the chrome/grey out of focus square blob.



  • Remove the parts to get the the helicoids

    Nothing too complicated in at this point, remove the rear mount and pull off the aperture ring, remove the screws to free the focus ring and then the aperture coupler screw.





    Remove the 3x screws on the chrome grab ring and slide off towards the rear - remove the detent spring (after marking one side of it) as its easier to reassmeble.

  • Mark the infinity position on the rear and central helicoid
  • Separate the outer and central helicoids

    These steps will be very familiar for anyone who has serviced a 50mm f/2 AI and the like. The helicoid post is at the TOP, towards the front for the lens and the lip faces the rear. Unscrew the helicoid key screws and slowly seperate, marking the off separation point.



  • Separate the central and inner helicoids

    The inner helicoid separates towards the front of the lens (unlike the 50mm f/2 AI). Mark the position of seperation

  • Clean and relube the helicoids

    Clean with the usual tissues, lighter fluid, dish soap, kitchen grease remover (Cilit Bang kitchen grease remover works well once you've done with lighter fluid!) and final clean with more lighter fluid and IPA. When ready use a thin layer of soft grease, like NPC BC-13A, on the inner helicoid surface and very thin on the central helicoid mating surface. The front optical block with its 8 elements sit on this helicoid so we want the helicoid not to bind. Once remated turn them to ensure its not too heavy but not too dry.

    A thin layer on the central helicoid as you mate to the outer helicoid.

    The helicoids on this lens aren't very troublesome to remate.

Obscured Problems

This lens was came to me with a description concerning the manual focus performance: it was quick to see that the focus was broken and exposure/iris settings were not working correctly with f/8 being 2 stops under exposured.

Broken Helicoid Key

The helicoid key in this lens was broken, with the central post gone. Since this lens is not common sourcing a helicoid from antoher 18mm f/4 AI was simply not feasible. However the helicoid key from a 1971 Nikkor-H 28mm f/3.5 lens surprisingly did work, matching the width and screw hole locations and importantly curvature of the inner helicoid albiet the post looking a little short and having an thinner key base thickness.



Miscalibrated Aperture - resetting the Zero Point

As the lens is stopped down from f/4 -> f/5.6 -> f/8 -> f/11 it was very clear the exposures were off: The exposures from the lens:
  • f/4 is fine
  • f/5.6 is about 0.5 under exposed
  • f/8 seems to be about 2 stops under-exposured (very visible - i've seen this shooting in the sky too)
  • f/11 very very very under-exposed
The fix to this was to adjust the aperture iris, sliding it to affect how far the blades opened from wide open position.



With the optical block in the lens in the housing and the aperture ring set to f/4 (widest setting), mark on the aperture/optical block where the aperture pin sits - this does not have to be tight at the edge with the slot the pin sits. Removing the optical/aperture block from the barrel, loosen the 3x screws securing the iris plate mechanism.

At this point we need to setting the aperture/iris zero point. Whilst holding the aperture pin at the wide open position and the aperture activation lever in the stopped down nudge the iris securing screws (and thus adjusting the iris plate) whilst observing the aperture blades as they come in/out of view from the rear. We want to adjust so the blades are just out of the way - test that when the aperture activation level is released/held there is no movement of the aperture blades into the image light path.

Secure the 3x screws whilst holding the aperture activation lever to try to avoid any excessive movement of the iris plate - reassemble the and test the exposures: shooting a white object (paper or monitor) filling a large part of the frame will give you a spike on the histogram and stopping down (just keep the same shutter settings) you should see the histogram spike move down a stop. If the spike moves more or less you will need to adjust the iris plate again. Repeat zeroing the iris position until you have a set of exposures that look right. As this is not scientific its not going to be perfect but its significantly better than a 2 stop under exposure!

Conclusions

I find the old wide-angle Nikkors relatively fun to shoot with because of their perceived optical flaws, in particular ghosting. In terms of pure resolving power and edge-to-edge sharpness, this lens doesn't compare to modern equivalents - and dare I say even some modern kit lenses like the Nikkor 18-55mm DX. Yet when color and tonal rendering are factored in, it holds up surprisingly well: the 18mm f/4 AI has less in your face saturation and a gentler highlight roll-off than modern high-contrast lenses. For the era it was designed, flare handling is also impressive, sitting just behind the 20mm f/3.5 AI and 20mm f/4 AI. Still, it wouldn't be unfair to call the 18mm f/4 AI an adequate optical performer rather than an outstanding one. Other legacy Nikkors have held up better by modern standards (Nikkor 28mm f/2.8 AI-S, Micro-Nikkor-P 55mm f/3.5, and even the punchier Nikkor 20mm f/4 AI), whereas the 18mm f/4 AI doesn't quite reach that tier.

Again using the 20mm focal length as a benchmark - obviously the 18mm is wider, though in the legacy AI/AI-S space they naturally compete as wide options. Physically compared to the vintage 20mms, the focus throw is the shortest (at 70 degrees) and the lens is the heaviest of the three at around 320g, while the large 86mm filter ring makes it far less pocketable. However, this is a true 18mm giving a 100-degree field of view, and as with any ultra-wide, that extra 6 degrees is very noticeable and genuinely useful in tight spaces. Outside of architecture - where you have to be careful with parallel lines - using an 18mm for street photography can be hit and miss: the wider you go, the closer you need to get, and the perspective pushes background subjects further away, which brings its own compositional challenges.



Between its 100-degree perspective, rich primary colors, and forgiving tonal roll-off, the 18mm f/4 AI still offers distinctive look in its images even if its not clinicly modern. The 18mm f/4 AI has unique and interesting look and coupled with its relative scarcity that gives it real appeal for vintage manual shooters. There are certainly sharper modern - and even vintage - wide angle options available, though most people seeking out an 18mm f/4 AI today will know that already.

No comments:

Post a Comment